Readers, it's been a long and interesting journey from our
eight original pitches to the final three. Our discussions have been productive and illuminating, and I have no doubt that any of
Ankh-Theb,
Ekkremes, or
Frontier would be a fruitful design project. Nonetheless, the time has come to choose which set we're going to design. The Goblin Artisans authors will soon make a decision.
This thread is for feedback on that decision. Which set do you think has made the most progress during pre-design? What obstacles do you see ahead? Where is the best potential? What themes or mechanics are most exciting? Which questions are still unanswered?
This seems like as good a time as any to articulate our mission statement: we are trying to design a large standalone set using the standards of Magic R&D. Thus, we'll work within the framework of
New World Order,
the color pie,
player psychographics, etc. Please keep these issues in mind while commenting on the viability of our options.