I like it, but it feels weird that a red card would reward an opponent for gaining life. Pow Rup 1RCreature OrcPow Rup gets +1/+0 as long as an opponent has 20 or more life. 2/2
It rewards aggressive play, but I agree it reads off. Yours is better.
I thought the original was fine: it rewards you for bringing the life total down, on average, regardless of any extra life gain shenanigans.But if you prefer, you could reverse the sense. 1R 1/1 or 2/1 becomes 3/1 when opponent has less than their starting life.
Red and Blue have all of Magic's 4/1s for 2, however! :P
Orc Kelse 1RCreature - OrcAt the beginning of your end step, each player dealt damage by CARDNAME this turn gains 1 life.3/1
Weird.
Neat! Gaston 1WLegendary Creature - Human Warrior At the beginning of your upkeep each player gains 1 life 4/1
I like it, but it feels weird that a red card would reward an opponent for gaining life.
ReplyDeletePow Rup 1R
Creature Orc
Pow Rup gets +1/+0 as long as an opponent has 20 or more life.
2/2
It rewards aggressive play, but I agree it reads off. Yours is better.
DeleteI thought the original was fine: it rewards you for bringing the life total down, on average, regardless of any extra life gain shenanigans.
DeleteBut if you prefer, you could reverse the sense. 1R 1/1 or 2/1 becomes 3/1 when opponent has less than their starting life.
Red and Blue have all of Magic's 4/1s for 2, however! :P
ReplyDeleteOrc Kelse 1R
ReplyDeleteCreature - Orc
At the beginning of your end step, each player dealt damage by CARDNAME this turn gains 1 life.
3/1
Weird.
DeleteNeat!
DeleteGaston 1W
Legendary Creature - Human Warrior
At the beginning of your upkeep each player gains 1 life
4/1